Profits for All

From the 2025 November Quarterly Dispatch Newsletter

Would it have been better if the poor widow (see Mark 12: 41-44), rather than having only two coins to give to the temple treasury, had three?

What about four? How about one? … Even none?

God alone knows.

Christ, however, does not extol the woman because she is poor. See the passage: the reason he provides for why she gave more than all the rest was that, while others gave some of what abounded to them, she gave as much as she had. That’s a challenge to the poor and rich alike. And, at least from the perspective of the treasury, better that she had three coins than two!

There is spiritual profit to be gained in reflecting here, not just on how we should approach wealth, but even the work we do to attain it. Or even the lack thereof!

And all of these things have been twisted. Some quite subtly. In running from avarice, for example, sometimes we run to a different vice, all together!

Because there is no substitute for what is truly valuable, and us profiting in what matters, to God. What does this true value look like for any one person?

God alone knows.

[Mere] wealth, earthly success, hard work, or even poverty are not the same as God’s will. He may will these for some people and not others. We can’t say, for example, “That man is rich. He must be good or doing the will of God.” Wealth, hard work, and poverty are not ends in themselves.

The dangers of wealth are well known: ”profits over people” yard signs have yet to gain mass adoption. What good is it to labor for any extra wealth beyond what we can consume if we can’t take it with us? And it profits a man nothing if he gains the whole world but loses his soul (Mk. 8: 36)!

But the challenge of “people over profits” is not just for the C-suite. Everyone is subject to subtle temptations in this respect. Fudging time cards, scrolling social media, cutting corners, and taking eyes off the road can all be ways that we put some sort of gain above the human person.

Less well known, or at least less frequently extolled, are the virtues of wealth.

Profits, honestly gained, are indispensable. If my neighbor can perform a service for me for $10 that would cost me $20, while costing them only $5, then they profit $5. And I profit the service. Also, I’m only out half of what I otherwise would be in terms of money.

Without profits, there is no division of labor, there is no trade, etc. Without any profits, there are no enterprises that could even have people to put profits over!

Another subtle temptation is to extol hard work as if it was an end in itself. There is a virtue with any hard work, but a trade-off, as well. You can work fiercely at the wrong thing, or as a distraction from the greater things.

You could dig a trench with a spoon, but should you? There are more effective ways (two spoons, for example!) and a trade-off from being more effective is you have more time and more resources to be used elsewhere! If what’s valued is a job done well and quick, then merely working harder can be a disservice.

Hard work doesn’t make things more valuable unless it’s the hard work that is valued.

In focusing on the laborer’s condition, as many discussions do, often neglected is consideration for the labored-for. Accounting, carpentry, oil-refining, delivery driving, management, and even marriage and parenting are for others. Doing them effectively involves providing value for others.

What about poverty?

The Church, it is observed, has a preferential option for the poor. Many models of the faith have lived and promoted a radical poverty. And Jesus said it was easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for one who is rich to enter the kingdom of heaven (Mt. 19: 24)!

Attentive reader’s will see that Jesus did not say it was easier for one who is poor to to enter the kingdom of heaven, but that it was impossible, without God, for anyone to enter the kingdom!

If it was good that the widow had so little to give—and so in this [having so little] was a model for us to imitate—then that would mean it’s better to not relieve poverty. It would be better if she had nothing!

At the very least, there are few, if any, who live with nothing. There are even very few who only possess the bare necessities. Moreover, we confess the Resurrection of the Body: stuff is an unavoidable certainty! Life is not an exercise in running from material creation.

The task, even for those who profess the evangelical counsel of poverty, is not to transcend things but to steward them. And the one who neglects his stewardship of wealth will be all the poorer because he will be at the mercy of those who exercise their influence over it.

As with so much in life, let us go to St. Joseph! He is a model for all when it comes to laboring for an eternal reward.

In Joseph we have a positive vision to strive after: life is not a game where we try to optimize our time and resources so as to end with no surplus or shortage in our bank account.

What we should be doing is seeking the face of the Lord, being zealous about creating value with all that we do, being attentive and receptive, and, above all, spending time with Jesus and Mary, and loving who and what they love.

What else is there? And who models this better than St. Joseph?

There’s an embarrassment of riches when it comes to how we can live this out. If St. Paul learned to be content in all things (Phil. 4), how much more would St. Joseph! All things can praise and serve God.

A setback for you can be an opportunity to instruct or even save others. This is well-illuminated in the Old Testament with Joseph, the son of Jacob: sold into slavery by his brothers, he was eventually the instrument through which God rescued his family from famine.

Of course, goods can be used for greater purposes, too. A bigger paycheck can mean a bigger family, or more material support for the church. Maybe that art education degree that the barista “isn’t using” could actually be put to good use even outside of being in a classroom. Many high view count explainer videos would say so!

Former liabilities can even become assets: J.D. Rockefeller famously turned oil refinery waste, i.e., what would have otherwise just been costs to his business, into hundreds of derivative products. Some aspiring entrepreneur had the idea of turning old tires into playground substrate. Life-saving penicillin is made from mold.

Everything can be profitable and everyone can live this out if we realize that every interaction, engagement, and chore is a chance for our own sanctification, to receive from God, and to reap the much more important spiritual harvest.

In sales there’s the adage of “A-B-C”: always be closing. The spiritual A-B-Cs could be “always be converting.” St. Peter, when asked for alms and having none didn’t waste the opportunity to heal, and evangelize, a cripple (Acts 3: 6).

We hope the Guild and its network can, in like manner, be a net that catches many souls! That’s how we can and should especially be about “our father’s business!”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top